Home | Sign Up | Log In | RSSTuesday, 2018-12-11, 0:23 AM


Site menu
Section categories
Education [150]
Videos [1]
Music [0]
Chat Box
learn c language learn c language branching and loop learn c language functions learn c language Pointer Basics how web page works Oracle Solaris 10 Oracle Solaris 10 How Web Pages Work Images How Web Pages Work Adding images&gr How Web Pages Work Introduction to How to Install WAMP How to Host Your Own Website for Fr How to Install the Apache Web Serve Atomic Structure The text provides 000 tons of conversations Introduction to How Radio Works Rad often over millions of miles citizens band radio Introduction to How the Radio Spect Can information travel faster than How F-15s Work by Tom Harris Browse How F/A-18s Work by Robert Valdes B How F/A-18s Work by Robert Valdes B Flying Video Game: In the Cockpit I How F/A-22 Raptors Work by Gary Wol 10 Unidentified Sounds That Scienti 10 Things You Didn't Know About Ein Is glass really a liquid? by Laurie How Radio Works by Marshall Brain B How Radio Works by Marshall Brain B 10 Most Terrifying Vehicle Manufact How a Top Fuel Dragster Works by Ch but can Siri meet our nee How Siri Works by Bernadette Johnso How the Tesla Turbine Works by Will Lecture 1: Inflationary Cosmology: Lecture 2: Inflationary Cosmology: Lecture 4: The Kinematics of the Ho Lecture 5: Cosmological Redshift an Lecture 6: The Dynamics of Homogene Lecture 7: The Dynamics of Homogene Lecture 8: The Dynamics of Homogene Lecture 9: The Dynamics of Homogene Lecture 10: Introduction to Non-Euc IBPS Clerical Cadre Exam Pattern De Institute of Banking Personnel Sele Educational Qualifications: A Degre INTERVIEW Candidates who have been official trailer for Mission Imposs How Relativity Connects Electric an in 1738 Kinetic Theory of Gases: A Brief Re Frames of Reference and Newton’s La attempts to measure the UVa Physics 12/1/07 “Moving Clocks Run Slow” pl More Relativity: The Train and the 12/1/07 The Formula If I walk from Adding Velocities: A Walk on the Tr 3/1/2008 The Story So Far: A Brief Mass and Energy Michael Fowler Energy and Momentum in Lorentz Tran How Relativity Connects Electric an Analyzing Waves on a String Michael by f even earlier than the bra Fermat's Principle of Least Time 9/ Hamilton's Principle and Noether's meaning they have Mechanical Similarity and the Viria Hamilton's Equations 9/10/15 A Dyna A New Way to Write the Action Integ Maupertuis came up with a kind of p Maupertuis' Principle: Minimum Acti Canonical Transformations Point Tra Introduction to Liouville's Theorem Adiabatic Invariants and Action-Ang Hyperbolas Michael Fowler Prelimina Mathematics for Orbits: Ellipses Keplerian Orbits Michael Fowler Pre Newton's equations for particle mot Dynamics of Motion in a Central Pot A Vectorial Approach: Hamilton's Eq Elastic Scattering Michael Fowler B Driven Oscillator Michael Fowler (c Dynamics of a One-Dimensional Cryst I usefor the spring constant (is a a mass on a spring Motion in a Rapidly Oscillating Fie Anharmonic Oscillators Michael Fowl in which the distance betw Motion of a Rigid Body: the Inertia Moments of Inertia: Examples Michae Euler's Angles Michael Fowler Intro or more precisely one our analysis of rotational motion h Euler's Equations Michael Fowler In Motion in a Non-inertial Frame of R Ball Rolling on Tilted Turntable Mi live cricket score roll the ball ba

Total online: 1
Guests: 1
Users: 0
Home » 2015 » August » 12 » How Relativity Connects Electric and Magnetic Fields
8:51 PM
How Relativity Connects Electric and Magnetic Fields

How Relativity Connects Electric and Magnetic Fields

Michael Fowler, University of Virginia

A Magnetic Puzzle…

Suppose we have an infinitely long straight wire, having a charge density of electrons of –λ coulombs per meter, all moving at speed v to the right (recall typical speeds are centimeters per minute) and a neutralizing fixed background of positive charge, also of course λ coulombs per meter.  The current in the wire has magnitude I = λv (and actually is flowing to the left, since the moving electrons carry negative charge). 

Suppose also that a positive charge q is outside the wire, a distance r from the axis, and this outside charge is moving at the same exact velocity as the electrons in the wire.

What force does the positive charge q feel?

The wire is electrically neutral, since it contains equal densities of positive and negative charges, both uniformly distributed throughout the wire (the illustration above is of course schematic).  So q feels no electrical force.

However, since q is moving, it will feel a magnetic force,  

The magnetic field lines are vertical circles centered along the axis of the wire, the field being into the page where the charge is (remember the current is to the left) and of magnitude

so the force on the charge is of magnitude

and is directed away from the wire, so the charge will accelerate away from the wire.

Now let us examine the same physical system in the frame of reference in which the charge is initially at rest.  In that frame, the electrons are also at rest, but the positive background charge is flowing at v:

What force does q feel in this  frame?

Since q is at rest, it cannot feel a magnetic force: such forces depend linearly on speed!

Yet it looks as if it can’t feel an electric force either, because the positive and negative charges in the wire have equal densities, right?  This leads to the conclusion that q feels no force at all in this frame, so it won’t accelerate away from the wire, as it did in the other frame.   This is of course nonsense—so where did we go wrong?

… Solved Electrically!

The mistake was in ignoring the relativistic Fitzgerald-Lorentz contraction, even though the velocities involved aremillimeters per second!   In the frame in which the wire is at rest, the positive and negative charge densities exactly balance, otherwise there will be extra electrostatic fields that the electrons will quickly move to neutralize.  However, thisnecessarily means that the densities cannot balance exactly in the frame in which the drifting electrons are at rest.

In the electrons’ rest frame, the positive charges, which had density λ coulombs per meter in their rest frame, are moving at speed v, so relativistic contraction will increase their density to:

On the other hand, in this electron frame the electrons are at rest, so their density is actually less than it was in the frame of the wire, it has decreased by λv2/2c2

The net effect is that the wire, electrically neutral in the lab frame, has a positive charge density λv2/c2 in the frame of the moving electrons (and the outside charge).  Recall Gauss’s Law relating the total electric field flux through a surface to the enclosed charge,


Exercise: use this to verify that the electric field from an infinite line of charge λ coulombs per meter has magnitudeλ/2πrεat distance r from the line charge.

From the exercise result, the electrostatic force on the charge q is:

where in the last step we used .

This purely electrical force is identical in magnitude to the purely magnetic force in the other frame!  So observers in the two frames will agree on the rate at which the particle accelerates away from the wire, but one will call the accelerating force magnetic, the other electric.  We are forced to the conclusion that whether a particular force on an actual particle is magnetic or electric, or some mixture of both, depends on the frame of reference—so the distinction is rather artificial.

A much more complete analysis of the fields from moving charges can be found in Purcell, Electricity and Magnetism, McGraw Hill, 1985.  We have chosen the simplest possible example to illustrate the basic point that electric and magnetic fields are frame-dependent concepts.

Category: Education | Views: 358 | Added by: farrel | Tags: How Relativity Connects Electric an, University of Virginia A Magnetic P | Rating: 0.0/0
Total comments: 0
Name *:
Email *:
Code *:
Log In
Entries archive

Copyright eduCampus.tk © 2018
Powered by uCoz